Working hard in the background...
Working hard in the background...
A side-by-side comparison of ratings, customer experience, products, fees, and pros & cons to help you choose the right bank.
VS
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC) edges ahead on our overall rating (4.1 vs 4.0), but the right pick depends on which products and fees matter most to you.
Overview
ATB Financial is a provincially-owned bank with $110 billion in assets under management. What started as a small treasury branch has transformed into what ATB Financial calls “the largest financial institution headquartered in Western Canada.” Its operations are mainly in Alberta, though in 2023, ATB Wealth, its full-service brokerage, first expanded outside of the province. As of 2026, the wealth management arm has locations in both British Columbia and Saskatchewan.
With a range of financial services, ATB offers its customers access to chequing and savings accounts as well as credit cards, mortgages, business banking and wealth management. Its savings rates are more competitive than the biggest banks in Canada, offering slightly better returns on savings. It still trails the digital banks, though.
The institution also has several credit cards available to Alberta residents. Each of the cards has different perks, including cashback or rewards, though eligibility restrictions and constraints on rewards means their credit card offering lacks in comparison to the larger banks.
ATB also has a range of lending products as well as business banking and access to investment services through ATB Wealth and ATB Cormark Capital Markets. The bank offers more depth than many smaller regional institutions. And more than the digital banks. Its Alberta focus, however, makes it less convenient for Canadians who live outside of the province. For anyone inside its core market, ATB may be a strong full-service alternative.
Known as CIBC, the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce sits among the biggest banks in Canada. Customers seeking full-service banking can access a range of banking, borrowing and investing options. Its product lineup is comparable to the other major banks, though some of its savings rates and fees are less competitive.
CIBC’s banking includes accounts for students, seniors, foreign workers, and newcomers to Canada. The CIBC Smart Account is one of its core everyday banking products and comes with a monthly fee rebate when customers maintain the minimum balance. While it may appeal to those who qualify, other customers might find more value elsewhere.
The bank has a wide selection of credit cards including those for cash back, travel, Aeroplan, Aventura and Costco. Its borrowing options are also comprehensive including mortgages, personal loans, lines of credit and home equity borrowing. CIBC’s product lineup as well as its highly rated online and mobile banking tools make the bank a well-rounded choice for Canadians looking to build a banking relationship with a single institution.
Overall rating
4.0
4.1
Customer experience
3.3
3.1
Best for
ATB Financial works best for Albertans who want a full-service banking relationship within a regional institution.
CIBC is best for Canadians looking for a traditional banking experience with a broad range of products. It may be especially appealing for customers who value a strong mobile banking experience but still want the option to visit a branch when needed.
Pros & cons
Pros
Strong regional presence in Albera with more than 300 locations across the province
ATB Wealth expansion into areas outside of Alberta
Full-service product lineup including banking, lending, wealth management and capital markets
Competitive product lineup with unlimited banking and a no-fee digital account
Some savings accounts offer better rates than traditional Big Five savings accounts
More competitive loan and lending rates than the major banks
Cons
Primarily services Alberta so it is less convenient for those outside the province
Savings rate are still modest in comparison to digital high-interest savings accounts
Smaller credit card lineup compared to the major banks
Rewards program points are slightly less valuable than those from the bigger banks
Public customer reviews are mixed with complaints about service quality
Pros
Broad product lineup for both banking and investing options as well as borrowing
Strong credit card selection
Fee rebates available for eligible accounts
Highly rated mobile banking tools
Access to US dollar and cross-border banking
Cons
Monthly account fees are high for customers who do not qualify for fee rebates
Lower relative savings rates compared to many online banks
Mixed customer reviews surrounding service wait times and issue resolution
Few no-fee banking options
on ATB's website
Welcome Bonus
N/A
Monthly Fee
$0
Account Type
Chequing • Personal
Account Fees
Monthly Fee
$0
eStatement
Included

4 Our rating
on ATB's website
Welcome Bonus
Earn up to $900* for new customers
Monthly Fee
$24.95 (waivable)
Account Type
Chequing • Personal
Account Fees
Monthly Fee
$24.95
eStatement
Included

3.9 Our rating
on CIBC's website
Welcome Bonus
Bundle to earn up to $850†,‡ in value
Regular Interest
Up to 0%
Monthly Fee
$16.95 (waivable)
Account Type
Chequing • Personal
Step 1: Open a CIBC Smart Account and set up one recurring direct deposit for a minimum of $500 within two months. The direct deposit should be from your employer, the government or a pension.
Step 2: Get $500 with your Smart Account plus as much as $350 with a CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite Card with qualifying actions†,‡ Earn 10% cashback in an amount up to $200 on net purchases of up to $2,000‡. Earn $50 in a cashback bonus by setting up your first pre-authorized payment.
Account Fees
Monthly Fee
$16.95
eStatement
Included
ATM Fees
Own Network
$0
Canadian ATMs
$2
International
$5
on CIBC's website
Welcome Bonus
N/A
Regular Interest
Up to 0%
Monthly Fee
$4
Account Type
Chequing • Personal
Account Fees
Monthly Fee
$4
eStatement
Included
ATM Fees
Own Network
$0
Canadian ATMs
$2
International
$5

2.55 Our rating
on ATB's website
Welcome Bonus
Earn total interest of up to 4.60%* for your first 90 days
Regular Interest
Up to 0.6%
Monthly Fee
$0
Eligible clients can get a total interest rate of 4.60%* during their first 90 days from a special bonus of 4.10%.
on CIBC's website
Welcome Bonus
N/A
Regular Interest
Up to 0.6%
Monthly Fee
$0
on ATB's website
Welcome Bonus
40,000 points
Annual Fee
$120 $0
Interest Rates
20.99% / 22.99%
RECOMMENDED CREDIT SCORE
3.1/5
The ATB World Elite Mastercard offers impressive rewards and insurance coverage, making it ideal for high-income Alberta residents seeking premium travel perks. However, the low point value and high income requirements might limit its appeal for some users.
Pros
Cons
Rewards
The accelerated earn rate applies to the first $50,000 in annual purchases on the account, at merchants qualifying for the accelerated earn rate, per calendar year based on your statement cycle date. The annual spend cap for the accelerated earn rate resets every January. Once the combined cardholder spend exceeds this threshold in these categories, they will continue earning points at the regular earn rate of 2 points per $1 spent in purchases.
Insurance
Coverage
Purchase Protection
Extended Warranty
Car Rental Accident
Car Rental Damage & Theft
Car Rental Personal Effects
Travel Medical Insurance (64 & under)
Common Carrier Travel Accident Insurance
Flight Delay
Baggage Delay
Trip Cancellation
Trip Interruption
Lost or Stolen Baggage
Hotel Burglary Insurance
Personal Effects
Price Protection
Benefits
Details
Airport Lounge - Dragon Pass
Car Rental Discount
Boingo Wi-Fi hotspot
Eligibility
Credit Score
Annual Income
on CIBC's website
Welcome Bonus
Balance transfer 0% interest for up to 10 months with a 1% transfer fee‡
Rewards Rate
No Rewards
Annual Fee
See Rates
Interest Rates
13.99% / 13.99%
RECOMMENDED CREDIT SCORE
4/5
A nice low rate card for everyday spending.
Pros
Cons
Rewards
No rewards earned on this card
Insurance
Coverage
Common Carrier Travel Accident Insurance
Benefits
Details
Gas Discount†
Discount††
Eligibility
Credit Score
Annual Income
All products offered
17 products
Credit cards
CIBC Aeroplan® Visa Infinite Privilege* Card
CIBC Aeroplan® Visa Infinite* Card
CIBC Aeroplan® Visa* Card
CIBC Aventura® Gold Visa* Card
CIBC Aventura® Visa Infinite Privilege* Card
CIBC Aventura® Visa Infinite* Card
CIBC Aventura® Visa* Card
CIBC Aventura® Visa* Card for Business
CIBC bizline® Visa* Card
CIBC Costco Mastercard
CIBC Dividend Platinum® Visa* Card
CIBC Dividend® Visa Infinite* Card
CIBC Dividend® Visa* Card
CIBC Select Visa* Card